Case study · Annotation
A university research lab clears a 3,400-episode backlog and moves its old labels to a new 14-action list.
- episodes labelled
- 3,400
- weeks, vs a 9-month estimate
- 5 wks
- of auditedA second annotator labels a sample of episodes on their own, and the two sets of labels are compared. boundaries within 0.2 s of a second annotator
- 96%
- of episodes sent back for rework
- 2.1%
The situation
3,400 episodes over 18 months: 1,100 had one action label each, the rest had none. The lab's next policy needed every step segmented, on a new list of 14 actions.
What they asked for
- Where does each step start and end, to within 0.2 s?
- Which episodes include a second attempt at a step?
- Can the 1,100 old labels move to the new action list, or must they be redone?
What Talo delivered
Tracks for both hands and every object, segments from the 14-action list and a task description, in the lab's existing dataset format.
episode 2207 · pour_water · 0 to 24 sleft arm, 1 of 2
Old label
New labels
The second grasp is labelled "retryA second attempt at the same step after the first one failed, such as a missed grasp.", so the lab can keep it or filter it out for each experiment.
820 old labels moved to the new list. 280 were redone.
| Old labels | What happened | Episodes |
|---|---|---|
| Clear single action | Split into segments from the new list | 820 |
| Wrong or ambiguous | Labelled again from the video | 280 |
| No label | Labelled from scratch | 2,300 |
How it ran
- 1
Rules, week 1
Talo and the lab wrote a definition for each of the 14 actions, with the cue that starts and ends it and two sample clips.
- 2
Pilot, 50 episodes
The lab reviewed the pilot batch and changed three rules, including where "lift" ends and "pour" begins.
- 3
Weekly batches
Two passes per episode. A second annotator audited 10% of each batch, and the lab spot-checked every delivery.
Outcome
Returned episodes came back within the same week. The written rules can be cited in the paper.
The automatic first pass, on a public dataset
Episode 0 of Unitree's open G1 pouring dataset: a humanoid with two dexterous hands, driven by a teleoperator. The chart shows two signals from the robot's joint data. Move across it, pick a segment, or play the episode.
| Segment | Time |
|---|---|
| 0.0 to 2.7 s | |
| 2.7 to 3.4 s | |
| 3.4 to 4.7 s | |
| 4.7 to 9.2 s | |
| 9.2 to 12.3 s | |
| 12.3 to 12.6 s | |
| 12.6 to 14.9 s |
Across all 311 episodes (68 minutes)
Have a backlog of recordings? We label a small batch of your own footage first.
Request an annotation pilot Next: household collection →